New Italian Restaurant in Sarasota: Full Review of Bar Italia at Waterside

Okay, let’s talk about Bar Italia. This place is not your typical restaurant—it’s like a little slice of Italian heaven right here in Lakewood Ranch. And bonus? It’s only a four-minute drive from my house, which means I’m basically living the dream. Honestly, I’d go back 1,000 times if I could. Scratch that—I will go back 1,000 times.
First off, the vibe: colorful, vibrant, modern, and dripping in those dark, moody Italian feels. Picture chic date night meets “I’m pretending I’m in a trendy Roman trattoria.” Their artwork? Chef’s kiss. The staff? Chef’s kiss.
Now, the food. Ohhh, the food. It’s excellent, and I’m talking “I will dream about this pasta” levels of excellence. Plus, the price is right. You’re not walking out of here clutching your wallet in despair, which is rare for a place that feels this fancy. They’ve nailed that elusive balance of fancy without being snooty.
The only catch? This place is popular. Like, “I hope you have a reservation or you’ll be staring longingly at other people’s plates for a while” popular. But hey, popularity doesn’t happen by accident. It’s worth planning ahead, trust me.
Bar Italia feels like the perfect blend of chic and cozy, where modern vibes meet a dash of old-school Italian charm. If you haven’t been yet, fix that immediately. And if you’re already a regular, I’ll probably see you there. Save me a seat, okay?







I’d love to hear what you ordered, what you loved, or even what you’d skip next time. Drop your favorite dishes—or any Sarasota Italian spots I should try next—in the comments below!